Topic: Hierarchical Structure of Courts

Search 500 + past questions and counting.
Professional Bodies Filter
Program Filters
Subject Filters
More
Tags Filter
More
Check Box – Levels
Series Filter
More
Topics Filter
More

Which courts constitute the Superior Courts and what are their unique features? (6 marks)

The Ghanaian court system and the Judiciary comprise both the Superior Courts of Judicature and the Lower Courts. The Superior Courts in descending order are as follows:

  • The Supreme Court
  • The Appeal Court
  • The High Court
  • The Regional Tribunal
  • The Circuit Court
  • The District Court
  • Juvenile Court
  • National House of Chiefs
  • Regional House of Chiefs
  • Traditional Council

(Any 6 points for 6 marks)

Abaabase Ltd, a printing company located on the Main Campus of the University for Development Hohoe, employed Kweku Ofori as a new store keeper with HND Purchasing & Supply qualification in January 2017. He started very well but because the controls were deficient, he was able to steal GH¢28,500 worth of paper and cartridge for his private photocopying business which is run on the same University Campus. After an audit exercise, this deal was discovered and the Chief Executive Officer has directed that the company takes both civil and criminal action against Kweku Ofori. Courts impose punishment on convicts according to their respective jurisdictions.

As a Business Law Student, the Chief Executive Officer has asked you to advise him on the appropriate court in which this case can be filed and why? (4 marks)

The court to seek redress on the matter of Abaabase Ltd is the Circuit Court which has a maximum amount within its jurisdiction of GH¢50,000 as compared to the District Court which has GH¢20,000 as its limit.

State the Appellate structure of the court system of Ghana in civil matters. (4 marks)

  • Court of Appeal to the Supreme Court
  • High Court to Court of Appeal
  • Circuit Court to Court of Appeal
  • District Court to High Court

[Any 4 points at 1 mark each for a total of 4 marks]

List, in an ascending order, the Superior Courts of Ghana, as stated in the 1992 Constitution of Ghana.

  • Supreme Court
  • Court of Appeal
  • High Court/Regional Tribunal
    (2 marks each = 6 marks)

Mr. Biggs initiated a claim before the High Court at Agona Swedru for certain reliefs. These were based upon Mempeasem Communication Ltd’s allegedly unlawful acts of encroachment upon a piece of land belonging to Mr. Biggs’ family on which a telecommunication tower (mast) had been erected. The action went through a trial. At the end, the court held a judgment that accepted Mr. Biggs’ version of the matter and awarded damages of GH¢ 92 million against Mempeasem Communication Ltd.

Required:
You are working at Mempeasem Communication Ltd’s legal department as an intern. Your boss has asked you to advise him on whether or not the High Court decision, being a Superior Court, can be overturned by any other court. In addition, state if any, from which courts could further redress be sought?

The Supreme Court can utilize the power conferred on any other court in the realm to grant an order of stay of execution or overturn any earlier orders. Judicial precedent is an indispensable foundation upon which to decide the law and its application to cases. Accordingly, the power to depart from a decided case must be exercised with self-restraint and resorted to only when the court is convinced that the earlier decision was incorrect or such a departure is necessary to bring certainty to its decision to give credence to the doctrine of judicial precedent. The courts that further redress could be sought in this case are the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court. (10 marks)

“All the Courts in Ghana have jurisdiction in matters relating to the fundamental Human Rights of every citizen.”

Required:

Explain if the above is a true or false statement in terms of the provisions of the 1992 Constitution of the Republic of Ghana? (2 marks)

Chapter eleven of the Constitution of the Republic of Ghana 1992, relating to the Judiciary, confers on the High Court under article 140(2) the jurisdiction to enforce the Fundamental Human Rights as guaranteed by the Constitution. The Constitution has earlier in article 33(1) empowered a person who considers that their fundamental human rights and freedoms have, or are being, or are likely to be contravened to apply to the High Court for redress.

The Supreme Court under article 130 (1) of the Constitution of the Republic of Ghana, 1992, provides that subject to the jurisdiction of the High Court in the enforcement of fundamental Human Rights and freedoms as provided in article 33, the Supreme Court has jurisdiction in all matters relating to the enforcement or interpretation of the constitution. Implied therefore, is that the Supreme Court has an interest in matters of Fundamental Human Rights or Freedom.

Thus, under the Constitution of the Republic of Ghana, 1992, it is only the High Court that has jurisdiction in matters relating to Fundamental Human Rights and Freedoms.

State the courts in Ghana that have appellate jurisdiction.

(3 marks)

The judiciary under article 126 of the Constitution of the Republic of Ghana includes the Superior Courts of Judicature which are:

  • The Supreme Court
  • The Court of Appeal
  • The High Court and Regional Tribunals

The following courts in Ghana have appellate jurisdictions:

i) Under article 129 of the Constitution of the Republic of Ghana, the Supreme Court shall be the final court of appeal and shall have such appellate and other jurisdiction as may be conferred on it by the Constitution or by any other law. Appeal under article 131 lies from a judgment of the Court of Appeal to the Supreme Court on conditions.

ii) Article 137 provides that the Court of Appeal has jurisdiction throughout Ghana to hear and determine appeals from a judgment, decree, or order of the High Court and Regional Tribunal and such appellate jurisdiction as may be conferred on it by the Constitution or any other law.

iii) Article 140 (1) confers appellate jurisdiction on the High Court in civil and criminal matters and other jurisdiction as may be conferred on it by the Constitution or any other law.

Ten members of a club (Agro Club) trespassed on a piece of land belonging to a public school. The club erected a wooden structure on the land in which they were residing. When the school authorities noticed their presence, they were then asked to vacate the land, but they defied the warning. The school authorities served written notice on them to remove the structure they have erected on the land, and vacate same within five days or risked their structure being demolished. The club decided to take legal action against the school authorities in the Supreme Court.

Required:
Explain whether Agro Club will succeed in their court action. (5 marks)

The Supreme Court is the apex court of Ghana. Under article 129 of the Constitution of the Republic of Ghana, 1992, the Supreme Court shall be the final court of appeal and have such appellate and other jurisdiction as may be conferred on it by the constitution or any other law.

The claim by the ten (10) members of a club (Agro Club) is based on an alleged infringement of their human rights. The claim of the encroachment is grounded on an alleged infringement of their fundamental human rights by the school authorities under article 18 (1).

The 1992 Constitution states that if the claim is that which borders on infringement of one’s fundamental human rights, the appropriate forum is the High Court and not the Supreme Court.

Article 18 provides that every person has a right to own property either alone or in association with others. It is the right of the ten (10) members to erect a wooden structure on the land in which they were despite their trespass. Acquisition of property follows the law. Having a right to own property does not mean that one can encroach on or occupy any land at all irrespective of who owns that land and then claim it as one’s property.

It therefore constitutes trespass to land for anyone to enter the land of another person without the owner’s consent and refuse to leave when ordered to do so. The occupation by the encroachers of the school’s land without authority is unlawful.

The school can therefore eject them from the land without infringing any law. The ten (10) will fail in their action because their conduct is unilaterally occupying another person’s land.

Commencing the court action in the Supreme Court is inappropriate. The action should have been commenced in the High Court pursuant to article 33.

Article 130 provides for the exclusive original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court in:

i) all matters relating to the enforcement or interpretation of the Constitution; and ii) all matters arising as to whether an enactment was made in excess of the powers conferred on Parliament or any other authority or person by law or under the Constitution.

In the current scenario, the Agro Club decided to take legal action against the school authorities in the Supreme Court. By the provisions of articles 129 and 130 of the Constitution of the Republic of Ghana, the appellate and exclusive original jurisdictions of the Supreme Court do not fall within the matter under consideration. The Agro Club will therefore, not succeed in its court action.

In two points each, write short notes on the following: b) Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court (4 marks)

 

  • The Supreme Court is the final court of appeal and has exclusive original jurisdiction in the interpretation and enforcement of the Constitution.
  • It has supervisory jurisdiction over all courts and adjudicating authorities, and is the only court with the right to hear appeals that may come from the National House of Chiefs.

In two points each, write short notes on the following: a) High Court (4 marks)

 

  • The High Court has jurisdiction to enforce the Fundamental Human Rights and Freedoms guaranteed by the 1992 Constitution.
  • It has Supervisory Jurisdiction over all lower courts and any lower adjudicating authority, exercising administrative jurisdiction over administrative bodies, issuing prerogative writs, and determining appeals from the lower courts.