- 20 Marks
Question
The information in the financial statements of your client, Honesty Company Limited, represents claims by management in relation to its responsibility to prepare financial statements that give a true and fair view of the company’s state of affairs and results of operations for the year under review. These claims are referred to as financial statement assertions.
Required:
a) Outline the audit objectives for the audit of stock (inventories) in the financial statements. Your answer should relate to the financial statement assertions. (8 marks)
b) Discuss FOUR (4) sources from which evidence can be obtained to confirm the quantities and value of stocks. (8 marks)
c) Explain why stocks present high audit risk. (4 marks)
Answer
a) Audit Objectives for Stock (Inventories):
The audit objectives of stock (inventory) are based on ensuring the following financial statement assertions:
- Completeness:
- The objective is to ensure that all stocks belonging to the client at the balance sheet date have been reported or included in the financial statements.
- Existence:
- The objective is to confirm that the stocks physically exist at the balance sheet date.
- Rights and Obligations:
- The objective is to verify that the client has legal title to the stocks, or the entity holds or controls the rights to the stocks.
- Valuation and Allocation:
- The objective is to ensure that stocks are included in the financial statements at appropriate amounts, reflecting any necessary valuation or allocation adjustments, such as net realizable value or obsolescence.
- Presentation and Disclosure:
- The objective is to confirm that stocks are properly classified, presented, and adequately disclosed in the financial statements according to the applicable reporting framework.
(Each assertion for 2 marks, totaling 8 marks)
b) Sources of Evidence for Stock (Inventory):
Evidence on the quantity and value of stocks can be obtained from the following sources:
- Observation of Stock Taking:
- The auditor can attend the client’s physical stock count to observe the process and verify the quantities of stock counted. This provides direct evidence of the existence of stock.
- Stock Summary Sheets and Valuation:
- The stock summary sheets prepared by the client, and their reconciliation with inventory records, can provide evidence on stock quantities and their valuation. Checking the calculations on these sheets ensures accurate valuation.
- Client’s Stock Systems:
- For clients with perpetual inventory systems, evidence can be obtained from the continuous records maintained in these systems, which track stock movements in real time.
- Third-Party Confirmations:
- Where stock is held by third parties, confirmation from these third parties will provide evidence about the existence and quantity of stock held on behalf of the client.
(Each source of evidence for 2 marks, totaling 8 marks)
c) Why Stocks Present High Audit Risk:
Stocks present high audit risk for the following reasons:
- Lack of Double Entry Records:
- For most clients, stock quantities and values are not derived from double-entry bookkeeping but through physical stock counts and valuation, which can be manipulated by management to engage in fraudulent financial reporting.
- Materiality of Stocks:
- For many entities, stock represents a large proportion of the company’s assets. The materiality of such assets significantly increases the audit risk as errors or fraud can have a substantial impact on the financial statements.
(Each point for 2 marks, totaling 4 marks)
- Tags: Audit evidence, Audit Objectives, Audit Risk, Financial statement assertions, Inventory
- Level: Level 2
- Topic: Audit and Assurance Evidence
- Series: NOV 2019
- Uploader: Dotse